Jump to content

Photo

What can be done to make our class safer

- - - - - Saftey Seats HANS

  • Please log in to reply
84 replies to this topic

#21
Cnj

Cnj

    Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 487 posts
  • Location:Dallas
  • Region:Sw
  • Car Year:1999
  • Car Number:32
Joe, I agree in general with the physics of your hypothesis. Ie. That vertical compression is a velocity vectors game and angling the seat back creates a vertical spine compression on frontal impact with a steep(ish) seat slope, even when the car has no vertical acceleration. I disagree that F1 seats have 2.5" of padding. I've been in a F1 garage and the seat inserts did not show any padding at all. My guess is that even if it's safer to have padding, their higher priority is to get the driver as low as possible. I don't know what Indy cars have.

The published reports on safety of seats appears to suggest that holding the body securely with a molded (and very strong) seat dramatically reduces injury. However the same is not the same with the head which MUST have some energy retardation. Few seats in a club racing car are molded and so we have a lot of movement under impact and as Todd has noted, we have little if any head level retardation protection on the left side of Spec Miata seats. NASCAR moved thier seats slightly to center line to allow this.

Regardless of all this, I drove past Lee before the impact and his car was on a bank. It seems likely to me that Willy's car experienced rapid vertical acceleration on impact. If Willy had data in his car (accelerometers) - and decided to show this publically when he has recovered, then we would know what loads the car experienced. If the data capture rate was fast enough...

CNJ
We have a Winnah! - Won their 1st race... Congratulations! Bona fide - A bonafide Spec Miata driver

#22
ChrisA

ChrisA

    Veteran Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 659 posts
  • Location:Richmond, VA
  • Region:NCR
  • Car Year:1999
  • Car Number:58

 F1 and Indy have at least 2.5" of compressible impact materials under the but of the driver.  That helps prevent the compression injuries.  

 

Seems like a lot less in this F1 car cut-in-half video & PDF -  

http://www.sauberf1t...Infographic.pdf


Chris

 

Happiness is a dry martini and a good woman ... or a bad woman.
- George Burns


#23
Tom Hampton

Tom Hampton

    Egregious Member

  • SMembers
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 2,060 posts
  • Location:Mckinney, tx
  • Region:South west
  • Car Year:1992
  • Car Number:41

Lees car is in my possession. Both door bars are shaped like a banana. Lower bar ripped free of the main hoop taking a chunk with it. Upper bar pushed halfway thru the main hoop as expected because of angled design. Hit was below lower bar and unusual for us because lees car was nose high stuck on a bank. Rocker sill is almost touching the ground with 4.5 inch clearance at edges of front and rear. I'll point out cage was not designed for this type of upward hit. Hit and damage was made worse because of the car being dug in the mud.

I stopped and looked at it on my way home today.  Now I understand better.

 

The issue looks like the #8 car penetrated the seam between the lower door bar and the rocker panel.  Essentially, it rode up on the rocker panel and wedged its way between the lower bar and the rocker panel.  Attaching the lower bar to the rocker panel would effectively make the rocker panel part of the door bars and essentially ensure that the incoming car is caught by the steel net that is the door bars.  

 

I think the trick in that configuration would be ensuring that the welds to the rocker panel are strong enough to withstand the severe sheer forces in an impact of that magnitude.  

 

Looking at those door bars makes me want to go back and add lots of saddle gussets to the joints in mine.  


-tch
Build: www.tomhampton.info

video: vimeo.com/tomhampton

Support: X-Factor Racing

 

I didn't lose, I just got outspent!

Beta-Tester - Assisted us with beta testing the website. Donor - Made PayPal donation Bona fide - A bonafide Spec Miata driver

#24
chris haldeman

chris haldeman

    Veteran Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 928 posts
  • Location:Mckinney
  • Region:texas
  • Car Year:1999
  • Car Number:73
Wrap around saddle gussets are installed on the drivers side of all my recent cars. Wish for my own peace of mind that I had installed them too the pass side just too see how it held up
X-factorracing.com
3 podium finishes
2 2013 NASA nats
1 2013 Scca runoffs
Donor - Made PayPal donation Bona fide - A bonafide Spec Miata driver BFG Supertour Winner - Circuit of the Americas Winner - Majors Winner - Make it Rain - Made Paypal donation of $100+ We have a Winnah! - Won their 1st race... Congratulations!

#25
Tom Hampton

Tom Hampton

    Egregious Member

  • SMembers
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 2,060 posts
  • Location:Mckinney, tx
  • Region:South west
  • Car Year:1992
  • Car Number:41

To be clear, i was not criticizing you cage install, but rather my own.  Seeing the amount of bending and twisting that is present in that wreck...is eye opening.  

 

The video does not show how much the door bars moved, twisted, and bent very well.  The lower bar penetrates to the midline of the passenger footbox.  The upper door bar bent in to the plane of the eyeball vent, and is in an S shape.   As the upper bar was straightened, it pushed the front hoop and main hoop apart, which caused the main hoop to bent aft-ward.  

 

Ultimately, the cage did its job.


-tch
Build: www.tomhampton.info

video: vimeo.com/tomhampton

Support: X-Factor Racing

 

I didn't lose, I just got outspent!

Beta-Tester - Assisted us with beta testing the website. Donor - Made PayPal donation Bona fide - A bonafide Spec Miata driver

#26
Todd Lamb

Todd Lamb

    Driver Coach // Racer

  • SMembers
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 980 posts
  • Location:Atlanta, GA
We saddle gusset all our main joints. We also use large floor plates so nothing can tear away. Neither of these things would have made a difference in the TWS camera car.

We use a hans (aka shoulder harness bar) at the correct angle to reduce spinal compression. It sounds like maybe Willie's shoulder harnesses angled too far down behind the seat and caused spinal compression. I hope someone can shed light on this because this may be the most critical lesson of all here. Need details.

For the camera car I think the thing to recognize is that the lower pass side door bar was designed straight (nothing wrong with that), not bent out into the door, so I don't see major additional intrusion from the post incident screen grabs (have not seen car in person). I don't believe any of the major builders have a driver side lower bar configured like this pass side was. So this isn't indicative of what would happen on driver side with two door bars bent outward into the door.

Full disclosure: SMAC chairman, my opinions do not reflect anything to do with the SMAC unless specifically stated.

Todd Lamb
Atlanta Speedwerks
www.atlspeedwerks.com
SpeedShift Transmissions - reliability and performance

Spec Miata / Spec Boxster / Spec Cayman specialist

Spec MX-5 Challenge Series Director

Global MX-5 Cup team

MX5 Cup Champion - Has won a Season in the MX5 Cup Survive the 25, NASA Thunderhill - Survive the 25, NASA Thunderhill NASA Champs Winner - NASA Champs Winner ARRC Champion - Won the ARRC Race in a Spec Miata We have a Winnah! - Won their 1st race... Congratulations! Series Champ - Won a points based series in a Spec Miata Donor - Made PayPal donation Bona fide - A bonafide Spec Miata driver June Sprints winner  - June Sprints winner Majors Winner - World Challenge Winner - World Challenge Winner

#27
chris haldeman

chris haldeman

    Veteran Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 928 posts
  • Location:Mckinney
  • Region:texas
  • Car Year:1999
  • Car Number:73
Todd bottom bar was bent alittle. This was a Miata cage kit
X-factorracing.com
3 podium finishes
2 2013 NASA nats
1 2013 Scca runoffs
Donor - Made PayPal donation Bona fide - A bonafide Spec Miata driver BFG Supertour Winner - Circuit of the Americas Winner - Majors Winner - Make it Rain - Made Paypal donation of $100+ We have a Winnah! - Won their 1st race... Congratulations!

#28
Tom Hampton

Tom Hampton

    Egregious Member

  • SMembers
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 2,060 posts
  • Location:Mckinney, tx
  • Region:South west
  • Car Year:1992
  • Car Number:41

We saddle gusset all our main joints. We also use large floor plates so nothing can tear away. Neither of these things would have made a difference in the TWS camera car.

We use a hans (aka shoulder harness bar) at the correct angle to reduce spinal compression. It sounds like maybe Willie's shoulder harnesses angled too far down behind the seat and caused spinal compression. I hope someone can shed light on this because this may be the most critical lesson of all here. Need details.

For the camera car I think the thing to recognize is that the lower pass side door bar was designed straight (nothing wrong with that), not bent out into the door, so I don't see major additional intrusion from the post incident screen grabs (have not seen car in person). I don't believe any of the major builders have a driver side lower bar configured like this pass side was. So this isn't indicative of what would happen on driver side with two door bars bent outward into the door.

sorry, i didnt mean to imply that saddle gussets would have made a difference here---as the dont change the tubing strength.  the welds held.  My intent was that given the degree of bending and obvious stresses incurred here, i didn't want to rely on just welded joints, because of the potential consequence if one or more of these joints fails.


-tch
Build: www.tomhampton.info

video: vimeo.com/tomhampton

Support: X-Factor Racing

 

I didn't lose, I just got outspent!

Beta-Tester - Assisted us with beta testing the website. Donor - Made PayPal donation Bona fide - A bonafide Spec Miata driver

#29
Todd Lamb

Todd Lamb

    Driver Coach // Racer

  • SMembers
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 980 posts
  • Location:Atlanta, GA
I agree Tom - On the driver side I want gussets everywhere for that very reason.

Full disclosure: SMAC chairman, my opinions do not reflect anything to do with the SMAC unless specifically stated.

Todd Lamb
Atlanta Speedwerks
www.atlspeedwerks.com
SpeedShift Transmissions - reliability and performance

Spec Miata / Spec Boxster / Spec Cayman specialist

Spec MX-5 Challenge Series Director

Global MX-5 Cup team

MX5 Cup Champion - Has won a Season in the MX5 Cup Survive the 25, NASA Thunderhill - Survive the 25, NASA Thunderhill NASA Champs Winner - NASA Champs Winner ARRC Champion - Won the ARRC Race in a Spec Miata We have a Winnah! - Won their 1st race... Congratulations! Series Champ - Won a points based series in a Spec Miata Donor - Made PayPal donation Bona fide - A bonafide Spec Miata driver June Sprints winner  - June Sprints winner Majors Winner - World Challenge Winner - World Challenge Winner

#30
Todd Lamb

Todd Lamb

    Driver Coach // Racer

  • SMembers
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 980 posts
  • Location:Atlanta, GA
Belt mounting info:

www.schroth.com/installation-instructions/en/03_anchorage_locations_and_geometries.htm

Full disclosure: SMAC chairman, my opinions do not reflect anything to do with the SMAC unless specifically stated.

Todd Lamb
Atlanta Speedwerks
www.atlspeedwerks.com
SpeedShift Transmissions - reliability and performance

Spec Miata / Spec Boxster / Spec Cayman specialist

Spec MX-5 Challenge Series Director

Global MX-5 Cup team

MX5 Cup Champion - Has won a Season in the MX5 Cup Survive the 25, NASA Thunderhill - Survive the 25, NASA Thunderhill NASA Champs Winner - NASA Champs Winner ARRC Champion - Won the ARRC Race in a Spec Miata We have a Winnah! - Won their 1st race... Congratulations! Series Champ - Won a points based series in a Spec Miata Donor - Made PayPal donation Bona fide - A bonafide Spec Miata driver June Sprints winner  - June Sprints winner Majors Winner - World Challenge Winner - World Challenge Winner

#31
Bench Racer

Bench Racer

    Different strokes for different folks : )

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 5,508 posts
  • Location:Wauwatosa, WI
  • Region:Milwaukee
  • Car Year:1990
  • Car Number:14

Lees car is in my possession. Both door bars are shaped like a banana.

 

Lower bar ripped free of the main hoop taking a chunk with it.

 

Upper bar pushed halfway thru the main hoop as expected because of angled design.

 

Hit was below lower bar and unusual for us because lees car was nose high stuck on a bank. Rocker sill is almost touching the ground with 4.5 inch clearance at edges of front and rear. I'll point out cage was not designed for this type of upward hit. Hit and damage was made worse because of the car being dug in the mud.

 

Chris, curious questions with respect to potential learning.

 

Is there something to be learned from lower bar taking chunk with it. Presume main hoop parent material fractured some distance from the actual weld.

 

Does the upper bar pushed halfway thru the main hoop material show any main hoop material fracture away from the weld.

 

Understood, something fails under these impact conditions.

The metallurgy/welding folks could sift thru the responses to the above for potential future value.
 


Broken record - You are starting to sound like a broken record. Donor - Made PayPal donation Bona fide - A bonafide Spec Miata driver

#32
Keith Novak

Keith Novak

    Steadily Improving Member

  • SMembers
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,128 posts
  • Location:Seattle
  • Region:Northwest/Oregon
  • Car Year:1995
  • Car Number:88

I think the trick in that configuration would be ensuring that the welds to the rocker panel are strong enough to withstand the severe sheer forces in an impact of that magnitude.  

 

This may be more difficult than anticipated.  I'm not sure whether the rocker panels are plated (they are magnetic) and where the materials change from less rustable to more rustable, but as I was trying to pull some dents over the winter I found it very difficult to get a stud to stick on the underside for my dent puller, even after burnishing the surface with an angle grinder.


Donor - Made PayPal donation Bona fide - A bonafide Spec Miata driver We have a Winnah! - Won their 1st race... Congratulations!

#33
KW78

KW78

    Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 132 posts
  • Location:Co

The original topic here asks what we can do to be safer...

 

Discussions like this serve that purpose well which is great.

 

My opinions are based on a litany of car builds and cage builds for myself or customers, and I typically get to see the car safety eventually get tested somehow.   Not only SM, but other classes and rally, circletrack.  Like many here, alot of years of club racing experiences show alot of things.

 

First and foremost, SCCA and NASA have to get out of "CYA" mode anytime there is an incident.  All incidents should have a pictorial expose' shared and qualified comments or analysis discussed with club racers, especially in areas that may be subtle like belt angle or even the wrapping method.  Our education of reality vs. theoretical would jump up the curve quickly.  Instead, if the incident is serious, a tarp and yellow tape to keep people away is the first responsive.  It is very offensive really, to every participant.  The latest and by far the most serious incident I have been associated with at thunder hill had staff serving as crowd control attempting to prevent cell phone pictures before there was enough help for the driver on scene.

 

Second, everyone should realize that the SFI/FIA organizations are not in the business of finding the best safety equipment, rather the best safety equipment that will pay their licensing fees.  This creates problems both ways - there are examples of great equipment that won't pay the fees, and there are examples of poorer equipment that will pay the fees.  This is important because NASA and SCCA feel requiring the rating is some kind of liability insurance.  I agree we need good standards, but in the conversation of "how to get safer" there are significant problems in this area.

 

Third, specifically to SM and to road racing, we need to decide how many fires we are having, and how big a problem that is.  What is the propensity of fire causing incidents and how are they handled?  This is important, because our rules base, which has evolved since the time when fires were common, are making tradeoffs in this area that are causing injury today.  

 

The last thing I have time to add right now, is that I know of no one that pretends their SM is a street car.  The cage rules we use started as showroom stock, where it had to be a bolt in cage in order not to stiffen the chassis, as that is "against class philosophy".  Necessity stepped that up to a welded cage and a race seat, but with limited pickup points.  Now that can include seat support structure that doesn't count as pickup points.  We are the last class to have a pickup point limitation.  We should not.  We have a stiff car already with crappy shocks, so not only is more cage not going to increase the car handling at all, but even if it did it should be allowed.

 

My .02,

Kyle

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


  • Ron Alan, Rob Burgoon, Diller and 1 other like this
Bona fide - A bonafide Spec Miata driver

#34
Jamz14

Jamz14

    Veteran Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,310 posts
  • Location:California

The original topic here asks what we can do to be safer...

 

Discussions like this serve that purpose well which is great.

 

My opinions are based on a litany of car builds and cage builds for myself or customers, and I typically get to see the car safety eventually get tested somehow.   Not only SM, but other classes and rally, circletrack.  Like many here, alot of years of club racing experiences show alot of things.

 

First and foremost, SCCA and NASA have to get out of "CYA" mode anytime there is an incident.  All incidents should have a pictorial expose' shared and qualified comments or analysis discussed with club racers, especially in areas that may be subtle like belt angle or even the wrapping method.  Our education of reality vs. theoretical would jump up the curve quickly.  Instead, if the incident is serious, a tarp and yellow tape to keep people away is the first responsive.  It is very offensive really, to every participant.  The latest and by far the most serious incident I have been associated with at thunder hill had staff serving as crowd control attempting to prevent cell phone pictures before there was enough help for the driver on scene.

 

Second, everyone should realize that the SFI/FIA organizations are not in the business of finding the best safety equipment, rather the best safety equipment that will pay their licensing fees.  This creates problems both ways - there are examples of great equipment that won't pay the fees, and there are examples of poorer equipment that will pay the fees.  This is important because NASA and SCCA feel requiring the rating is some kind of liability insurance.  I agree we need good standards, but in the conversation of "how to get safer" there are significant problems in this area.

 

Third, specifically to SM and to road racing, we need to decide how many fires we are having, and how big a problem that is.  What is the propensity of fire causing incidents and how are they handled?  This is important, because our rules base, which has evolved since the time when fires were common, are making tradeoffs in this area that are causing injury today.  

 

The last thing I have time to add right now, is that I know of no one that pretends their SM is a street car.  The cage rules we use started as showroom stock, where it had to be a bolt in cage in order not to stiffen the chassis, as that is "against class philosophy".  Necessity stepped that up to a welded cage and a race seat, but with limited pickup points.  Now that can include seat support structure that doesn't count as pickup points.  We are the last class to have a pickup point limitation.  We should not.  We have a stiff car already with crappy shocks, so not only is more cage not going to increase the car handling at all, but even if it did it should be allowed.

 

My .02,

Kyle

A literary award yes Jim?


Broken record - You are starting to sound like a broken record. Donor - Made PayPal donation Sponsor / Advertiser - Site sponsor / advertiser... support these guys! Novel Approach - When a paragraph simply won't do... Make it Rain - Made Paypal donation of $100+ Bona fide - A bonafide Spec Miata driver

#35
Rob Burgoon

Rob Burgoon

    Veteran Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,465 posts
  • Location:San Diego
  • Car Year:1995
  • Car Number:91

The original topic here asks what we can do to be safer...

 

Discussions like this serve that purpose well which is great.

 

My opinions are based on a litany of car builds and cage builds for myself or customers, and I typically get to see the car safety eventually get tested somehow.   Not only SM, but other classes and rally, circletrack.  Like many here, alot of years of club racing experiences show alot of things.

 

First and foremost, SCCA and NASA have to get out of "CYA" mode anytime there is an incident.  All incidents should have a pictorial expose' shared and qualified comments or analysis discussed with club racers, especially in areas that may be subtle like belt angle or even the wrapping method.  Our education of reality vs. theoretical would jump up the curve quickly.  Instead, if the incident is serious, a tarp and yellow tape to keep people away is the first responsive.  It is very offensive really, to every participant.  The latest and by far the most serious incident I have been associated with at thunder hill had staff serving as crowd control attempting to prevent cell phone pictures before there was enough help for the driver on scene.

 

Second, everyone should realize that the SFI/FIA organizations are not in the business of finding the best safety equipment, rather the best safety equipment that will pay their licensing fees.  This creates problems both ways - there are examples of great equipment that won't pay the fees, and there are examples of poorer equipment that will pay the fees.  This is important because NASA and SCCA feel requiring the rating is some kind of liability insurance.  I agree we need good standards, but in the conversation of "how to get safer" there are significant problems in this area.

 

Third, specifically to SM and to road racing, we need to decide how many fires we are having, and how big a problem that is.  What is the propensity of fire causing incidents and how are they handled?  This is important, because our rules base, which has evolved since the time when fires were common, are making tradeoffs in this area that are causing injury today.  

 

The last thing I have time to add right now, is that I know of no one that pretends their SM is a street car.  The cage rules we use started as showroom stock, where it had to be a bolt in cage in order not to stiffen the chassis, as that is "against class philosophy".  Necessity stepped that up to a welded cage and a race seat, but with limited pickup points.  Now that can include seat support structure that doesn't count as pickup points.  We are the last class to have a pickup point limitation.  We should not.  We have a stiff car already with crappy shocks, so not only is more cage not going to increase the car handling at all, but even if it did it should be allowed.

 

My .02,

Kyle

 

Fantastic post.


Bona fide - A bonafide Spec Miata driver Survive the 25, NASA Thunderhill - Survive the 25, NASA Thunderhill We have a Winnah! - Won their 1st race... Congratulations!

#36
wheel

wheel

    Veteran Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 800 posts
  • Location:Kansas City
  • Region:KC
  • Car Year:1992
  • Car Number:20

I agree with Kyle.

I have spent a lot of time in my years on the ASAC and the CRB, fighting to eliminate restrictions on roll cages.  Why would be restrict the number of attach points and why would be mandate a cage that is less safe than another?  It took me four or five years to move ASedan off of the restricted cage rules.  "It will be a must have deal, because it will make the chassis stiffer?.  So what?  

There should be not restrictions on the number of attach points.  This rule should go away.

wheel

 

  1. Improved Touring, Spec Miata, B-Spec AND Touring (excluding T1) classes–The roll cage must attach to the vehicle structure within the passenger compartment in a minimum of 6 points and a maximum of 8 points as specified in these rules. 


  • Cnj likes this

#37
Johnny D

Johnny D

    Veteran Member

  • Moderators
  • 6,121 posts
  • Location:Fremont, CA
  • Region:San Francisco
  • Car Year:1999
  • Car Number:88
How about keep the min, and get the Max # to go away?
J~
2011 NASA Western Endurance Racing Championship E3 Champ
We have a Winnah! - Won their 1st race... Congratulations! Beta-Tester - Assisted us with beta testing the website. Donor - Made PayPal donation Bona fide - A bonafide Spec Miata driver Novel Approach - When a paragraph simply won't do... Survive the 25, NASA Thunderhill - Survive the 25, NASA Thunderhill Instigator - Made a topic or post that inspired other Make it Rain - Made Paypal donation of $100+

#38
Ron Alan

Ron Alan

    Veteran Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 3,732 posts
  • Location:Northern CA
  • Car Year:1995

How can improved driver safety be a negative? At a minimum, an attachment point to the rocker panel adjacent to the driver seat as Chris suggested earlier would seem like a no-brainer to me? The next thing would be to allow a modification to the floor so tall/long torso drivers drivers arent forced to have their helmet against the hard top or the seat laid back so far. Maybe spec a design or kit so this does not become a free for all? I will defer to the engineers on these items...because no doubt "to much" is not a good thing either! 


Ron

RAmotorsports

 

Donor - Made PayPal donation Bona fide - A bonafide Spec Miata driver

#39
wheel

wheel

    Veteran Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 800 posts
  • Location:Kansas City
  • Region:KC
  • Car Year:1992
  • Car Number:20

A letter to the CRB about the cage rule would get the idea back out there.  



#40
chris haldeman

chris haldeman

    Veteran Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 928 posts
  • Location:Mckinney
  • Region:texas
  • Car Year:1999
  • Car Number:73
I will be asking all of my customers too write a letter asking for door sill attachment allowance.
X-factorracing.com
3 podium finishes
2 2013 NASA nats
1 2013 Scca runoffs
Donor - Made PayPal donation Bona fide - A bonafide Spec Miata driver BFG Supertour Winner - Circuit of the Americas Winner - Majors Winner - Make it Rain - Made Paypal donation of $100+ We have a Winnah! - Won their 1st race... Congratulations!





Also tagged with one or more of these keywords: Saftey, Seats, HANS

0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users