I never had any luck with the cobalts.. seemed like an on/off switch to me and easily locked the tires. Then there would be 75% of the pad left and they heat cycled out. This was about 2008 when I tried them. Maybe different now
Thanks for the datapoint Jim. From what I gather, compound choice is very much driver preference. Regardless, here are my thoughts on pads that I've used.
Storytime:
Back when I had my S2k race car (2010-2012), I first used carbotechs, XP10/XP8 I think. They wouldn't hold up when they got too hot. They would fade, but never completely go away. But when they got that hot, they left glazed deposits all over the rotors which caused rough pedal feel. Easy on rotor wear...except for ruining the rotors when they glazed up. The carbotechs didn't wear out too fast, but who cares when the performance sucked. So then I switched to Hawk DTC-60. Much better for this application, better feel, higher friction, more initial bite which I like. Though sometimes the backing plates were too large and required filing to fit in the s2k caliper. Nasty dust that liked to rust onto the wheels, at least back then. Eventually I tried Cobalts on a friends advice, XR2/XR3. Loved them, similar friction and bite to the hawks, but the pedal feel was smoother and more consistent. The pads always fit in the caliper as the backing plate was the proper size. Didn't seem to get pad taper wear as much, and the pads lasted 50% longer than the hawks.
Then I built my PTE miata for 2013. Tried carbotechs again, same compounds, same story. Inconsistent performance, smeared rotors, yuck. Switched to the hawk DTC-60 again. Work great, low life though. The Hawks could do 3 weekends at most tracks, but not worth the risk of running out so I usually swapped after two. At least on the miata fitment, Hawk skimps on pad material. I recently measured the compound material thickness of a new hawk to a new cobalt, and assuming you remove pads from the car when they get to 1/8" material left, then the Cobalts had 25% more usable pad material than the hawks. Anyway, I never tried the cobalts on the PTE miata, as Hawk introduced a killer contingency program with NASA, so I've had basically free hawk pads for the last couple of years.
Which leads me to now, I plan to try Cobalts on the miata and see if I like them as much as I did in the S2k days. I have also heard excellent things about the PFC pads, so I am hoping to try them out at some point this season also. Perhaps the carbotechs have changed since 2013? Seems a lot of people do like them too, so perhaps it's worth giving them a second chance.